The Santa Fe Institute has launched an ambitious project in which leading complexity scientists comment on “foundational” papers. However, many of them are not foundational in the sense that they started a line of research that led to the complexity science of today; some of them are even foundational for lines of research that are rather distinct from complexity science. I […]
Category: Philosophy
The holistic tribes
This blog post is hopefully the beginning of the lecture notes for an upcoming course. Ultimately, I want to rectify the story of the development of ideas around complex systems, which has neither been a steady and well-informed progression nor a succession of Kuhnian paradigm shifts, but rather something messy and disconnected: a story of […]
What I was gonna say (Tractatus edition)
This is a post about how AI (if used to the best of our abilities) might rid science of its knowledge memes. Which are prone to become factoids, or overshadow more important results. While adding slides to my keynote talk at the inaugural Cudan conference on cultural data analytics, I wanted to say something about […]
The well-groomed anarchists: Why the world needs computational social science
The world needs computational social science, and it is not only, or even primarily, about the AI revolution. The reasons follow below and I also cover what a computational social scientist should know, do, and a few words about our hairstyles. Should it really be an academic discipline? Maybe this is changing, but five or […]
Human black boxes
Just some plain reflections that must have been expressed better by someone else, somewhere else. AIs are often criticized for being black boxes—good at predicting, but bad at explaining. They get it right, but we don’t know why. That AIs are black boxes doesn’t mean that humans are not (which is an opinion I often […]
The twilight of fantastical science
A post arguing that we shouldn’t give bonus points to off-beat and bold theories just because they are off-beat and bold. The allure of deep, hidden connections Probably we all had moments when we were seduced by the idea that there are unknown, hidden, long-ranging connections between seemingly distant parts of reality. The examples range […]
The road to nowhere… or explaining human cooperation
Here’s a new instance in a series of silly-dialogue blog posts (find others here, here, and here). Today, the study of the emergence of cooperation is a peculiar cocktail of applied math, behavioral economics, and theoretical population biology. I have found myself on either side of discussions about if this is the correct direction (depending on […]
Signs ‘O’ the times
A double-bill blog post with snarky comments about two trending ideas that I’m not much of an expert on. The state of disruption In a much-discussed paper from the beginning of the year, Park, Leahey, and Funk proclaimed that science is becoming decreasingly disruptive. This was somehow seen as a worrying trend, but imagine the […]
A better way of thinking about emergence
In this armchair-philosophy blog post, I’ll argue that we need to talk about emergence with scientific detachment, and one way of doing that would be to emphasize its role in explanation rather than as a phenomenon in itself. The eye of the beholder, after all The wonder of life itself is the wonder of emergence. […]
Analogies at the edge of reason
Making analogies is the engine of human intelligence, but for humanity as a whole, and our collective-intelligence enterprise called science, it is an obstacle. I’ll try to expand on that in this, maybe not sharpest of posts. Hypotheses In science and life alike, we use analogies as shortcuts to form hypotheses. Any other strategy—experimenting, making […]
Petter Holme 